NJ Clean Stream
njcleanstream.org
What green infrastructure actually looks like in a NJ neighborhood — and why it works better than pipes
Green infrastructure is not abstract. It occupies space in the public right-of-way, in parking lots, on rooftops, and in front yards. This article brings it down to earth — explaining what each type looks like in real New Jersey neighborhoods, how it works, what it costs, what co-benefits it delivers, and where its honest limitations lie.
Rain gardens: the most accessible green infrastructure tool
A rain garden is a shallow, planted depression that collects and infiltrates stormwater runoff from adjacent impervious surfaces. It is the most widely deployed, most cost-effective green infrastructure tool for residential and small commercial properties.
What it looks like. A typical residential rain garden is roughly oval or kidney-shaped, six to twelve inches deep, planted with native perennial plants — grasses, sedges, wildflowers, and shrubs — selected for tolerance of both periodic inundation and dry conditions. Positioned to receive runoff from a downspout, driveway, or yard, it collects water after a rain event, soaks it into the soil over 24 to 48 hours, and returns to its dry-weather appearance.
How it works. The depression provides temporary storage — holding stormwater that would otherwise flow rapidly off the property. The permeable soil allows infiltration, replenishing groundwater and supporting plants. Native plants with deep root systems enhance infiltration through macropores in the soil. A properly sized rain garden can infiltrate one to two inches of rainfall from the contributing area with no overflow.
Cost: Professionally installed residential rain garden: $1,000–$5,000. DIY installation with publicly available design guidance: a few hundred dollars in materials. Many municipalities with stormwater utilities offer installation subsidies or stormwater fee credits that significantly offset cost.
Real NJ examples. The Raritan Headwaters Association has supported hundreds of residential rain garden installations in the Raritan watershed. Municipalities in the Passaic River watershed have used state stormwater grant funding to install rain gardens in public parks and street rights-of-way.
Maintenance. Comparable to a conventional perennial garden bed — periodic weeding, replanting of dead plants, sediment removal from the ponding area every few years. Neglected rain gardens can accumulate sediment that reduces infiltration rates. Municipal programs that install rain gardens should have a plan for ongoing maintenance.
Bioswales: managing stormwater in the street right-of-way
A bioswale is a vegetated channel designed to slow, filter, and infiltrate stormwater runoff. Particularly effective for streets and parking lots — surfaces that contribute large volumes of both runoff and pollutants.
What it looks like. Street bioswales — sometimes called green streets — are typically installed in the space between the curb and the sidewalk, or in street medians. They are depressed slightly below the street surface, allowing water to flow in from curb openings during rain events. Planted with grasses, sedges, and shrubs selected for stormwater tolerance. In dense urban settings, structural soil cell systems allow tree planting above the bioswale. Parking lot bioswales are installed in the landscape islands between parking rows and along perimeter buffers.
How it works. Water enters through curb cuts or sheet flow, flows slowly through the planted channel, loses velocity through vegetation resistance. Sediment settles out; soluble pollutants are adsorbed to soil particles or taken up by plants; a portion infiltrates into underlying soil. Research documents nitrogen removal of 20–50 percent, phosphorus removal of 20–40 percent, and sediment removal of 60–90 percent in well-designed bioswale systems.
Cost: Street bioswale installation: $50–$200 per linear foot, depending on design complexity and existing utilities. Most cost-effective when installed as part of a street reconstruction project rather than as a stand-alone installation.
Real NJ examples. Hoboken has installed bioswales as part of its green infrastructure program, measurably reducing combined sewer overflow volumes. Newark has incorporated bioswales into street reconstruction projects in neighborhoods with high CSO frequencies. Several Middlesex County municipalities have installed bioswales in commercial corridors as part of MS4 permit compliance programs.
Green roofs: capturing stormwater at its source
A green roof is a roof surface covered with a growing medium and vegetation that captures and retains a portion of the rainfall falling on it.
What it looks like. The most common type for stormwater purposes is an “extensive” green roof — a thin (3–6 inch) growing medium layer planted with low-maintenance, drought-tolerant plants, primarily sedums. Lightweight (10–25 lbs/sq ft when saturated) and requiring minimal maintenance. An “extensive” green roof typically retains 50–80 percent of annual rainfall.
Additional benefits. Beyond stormwater retention, green roofs provide significant building energy benefits — reducing summer cooling loads by insulating the roof from solar radiation and providing evaporative cooling, and reducing winter heating loads by adding insulation. These energy savings can provide financial returns that partially offset installation costs.
Cost: Extensive green roof installation: $10–$25 per square foot versus $5–$10 per square foot for conventional roofing. The incremental cost is partially offset by energy savings and stormwater fee credits. Most cost-effective when installed at time of roof replacement.
Real NJ examples. Rutgers University has green roofs on multiple campus buildings. Several municipalities have installed green roofs on public buildings as stormwater management demonstrations. Private commercial property owners in communities with robust fee credit programs have installed green roofs to reduce their stormwater fee obligations.
Permeable pavement: letting stormwater where it wants to go
Permeable pavement systems allow water to infiltrate through the surface into a storage reservoir below, from which it infiltrates into underlying soil or is slowly released to a managed drainage system. Available as pervious concrete, porous asphalt, or permeable interlocking concrete pavers (PICP).
How it works. Water enters through void spaces or joints and collects in a crushed stone storage reservoir below the pavement. From the reservoir, it infiltrates into native soil or is slowly discharged through an underdrain. The reservoir provides temporary storage that reduces peak runoff rates and volumes. Well-designed systems on appropriate soils can manage the first inch or two of rainfall with no surface runoff.
Cost: Typically 20–50 percent more than conventional impervious pavement to install. Incremental cost is offset by reduced stormwater infrastructure costs, reduced maintenance costs, and stormwater fee credits. Life-cycle analyses frequently show permeable pavement to be cost-competitive with conventional pavement plus stormwater infrastructure over a 20–30 year timeframe.
Maintenance. Periodic vacuum sweeping to remove sediment that accumulates in pores or joints. Frequency depends on sediment load. Neglected permeable pavement can lose infiltration capacity; with appropriate maintenance, it can function for 20 years or more.
Urban trees: the undervalued green infrastructure asset
A single mature tree can intercept 1,000 to 4,000 gallons of rainfall per year through canopy interception — rainfall that hits the leaf surface and is evapotranspired without ever reaching the ground. A street tree with a 500 square foot mature canopy provides roughly the same stormwater management benefit as 500 square feet of high-quality bioswale at a fraction of the cost.
The co-benefits of urban trees — air quality improvement through particulate capture and ozone absorption, urban heat island reduction, reduced building energy costs from summer shade, aesthetic and property value benefits, wildlife habitat, positive mental health effects — make urban tree planting among the highest-value investments a municipality can make. Yet urban trees are systematically underinvested in New Jersey’s older cities, where the stormwater management need is greatest.
NJ Clean Stream is advocating for the incorporation of urban tree canopy targets into stormwater utility programs and MS4 permit compliance frameworks, recognizing trees as a formal green infrastructure category eligible for stormwater fee credits and stormwater grant funding.
The honest accounting: what green infrastructure can and cannot do
What it does well: More cost-effective than gray infrastructure for managing smaller, more frequent storm events that account for the majority of annual stormwater volume and pollutant loads. Delivers co-benefits — air quality, urban heat, green space, habitat — that gray infrastructure cannot. Distributes stormwater management function throughout the watershed rather than concentrating it in expensive centralized facilities.
What it cannot do alone: Less effective at managing large, infrequent storm events that generate runoff volumes exceeding what installed installations can infiltrate. Cannot solve combined sewer overflows in Newark, Trenton, Camden, and Paterson by itself. Cannot replace aging gray stormwater infrastructure that requires physical replacement. Dense urban cores with limited soil volume and complex underground infrastructure present real installation constraints.
The right approach: Maximum deployment of green infrastructure where site conditions allow and co-benefits justify the investment, combined with targeted gray infrastructure upgrades for portions of the system that cannot be adequately managed through distributed green approaches. That integrated strategy requires the dedicated, stable funding stream that stormwater utilities are designed to provide.
This is Article 2 of 3. Article 1 explains what stormwater utilities are and why many NJ towns are refusing to establish them. Article 3 provides a practical step-by-step guide for residents who want to push their town to adopt a stormwater utility.